India, May 19 -- In what was presumably meant to be a hard-hitting diplomatic counter to India's response after the 22 April Pahalgam massacre, a 'dossier' made by Pakistan intelligence agency, the ISI in collaboration with military commander, has instead emerged as a jumbled, poorly edited document that undermines its own credibility.

Meant to rally international sympathy and support, the 18-page file fails to present a coherent, persuasive narrative-and suffers not just from weak arguments, but also from glaring spelling mistakes, broken grammar, and propaganda-level tone.

The dossier, accessed by the Sunday Guardian, alleges that India orchestrated the Pahalgam attack as a "false flag" to justify military strikes on Pakistani territo...