New Delhi, Dec. 20 -- ESPN's College GameDay delivered a surprise during its live broadcast from College Station, Texas, on Saturday (December 20), ahead of the College Football Playoff first-round matchup between No. 7 Texas A&M and No. 10 Miami. Originally slated to feature Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Manziel as the celebrity guest picker, the show instead introduced Oklahoma City Thunder guard and former Texas A&M basketball star Alex Caruso for the popular picks segment.

The switch caught fans off guard, as Manziel had been announced earlier in the week. No official reason was provided by the College GameDay team for the last-minute change, and Manziel remained silent on the matter. Reports noted that Manziel was spotted in Miami th...