Nigeria, Dec. 31 -- The eagerness of the Isaaq-dominated leadership of the territory commonly known as Somaliland - now excluding Sool and much of Sanaag - to pursue secession from Somalia and seek diplomatic recognition from Israel defies political logic, historical experience, and basic strategic judgment.

The arguments advanced in support of Somaliland's secession have been debated for decades. While they resonate with segments of the Isaaq community, the overwhelming majority of Somalis reject the claim that secession is either justified or beneficial.

The state violence committed by the military regime that ruled Somalia between 1969 and 1991 against Somali citizens is well documented and was not limited to the Isaaq community, alt...