HC upholds husband's conviction in 34-year-old dowry death case
Lucknow, July 31 -- Rejecting the defence that a woman could have sustained burns while sprinkling seasoning for vegetables during the cooking process, the Lucknow bench of the Allahabad high court has upheld the conviction of her husband in a 34-year-old dowry death case dating back to June 1991.
Noting that the signs of the woman saving herself had not been found, Justice Rajnish Kumar passed the judgment on July 25. The HC dismissed the criminal appeal filed by the appellant Jai Shankar Shukla (the husband) of Unnao district against the verdict of the trial court, which had convicted him under Section 304-B (dowry death) of the IPC and sentenced him to 10 years' rigorous imprisonment. The court observed, "Thus, considering the material also, which includes the recovery memo, in which no sign or material of sprinkling of seasoning (chhaunk lagana) for vegetables has been found, because the wok (karahi) and vegetables were found kept separately near the clay stove (chulha) and burn thatch. It is also noticed that signs of saving herself by the deceased has also not been found because if she would have caught fire during sprinkling seasoning for vegetables, then she would have cried and tried to save her and the family members present at home or the neighbours could have reached to save her." According to the prosecution, the appellant got married about a year prior to the date of the incident and dowry was given in the marriage. The woman's husband and mother-in-law had been demanding Rs 5,000 two months prior to the incident, the prosecution added. During a visit to his daughter's house, the complainant told the husband and the mother-in-law that he was not in a position to give Rs 5,000 upon which he was threatened and not allowed even to meet his daughter.
On June 11, 1991, the father was informed that his daughter had been burnt. In the FIR, the woman's father-in-law stated that his daughter-in-law had died due to burns sustained from a fire in the thatch when she was preparing food clad in a nylon saree....
To read the full article or to get the complete feed from this publication, please
Contact Us.