HC judge ordered to sit with seniors after his 'worst order'
New Delhi, Aug. 6 -- The Supreme Court has directed that an Allahabad High Court judge be stripped of all criminal jurisdiction until his retirement and made to sit with a seasoned senior judge to understand the nuances of law, after finding his recent ruling to be one of the "worst and most erroneous" orders encountered by the top court.
The unusual direction, issued by a bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and R Mahadevan, came in a criminal matter where the high court judge, Justice Prashant Kumar, dismissed a plea seeking quashing of a criminal case based on what the apex court termed as a purely civil dispute.
"We are constrained to observe that the impugned order is one of the worst and most erroneous orders that we have come across in our respective tenures as judges of this Court... The judge concerned has not only cut a sorry figure for himself but has made a mockery of justice. We are at our wits' end to understand what is wrong with the Indian Judiciary at the level of High Court," said the bench in its order on Monday, expressing grave dismay over the judge's conduct.
It wondered whether such orders are passed on some extraneous considerations or it is sheer ignorance of law.
"Whatever it be, passing of such absurd and erroneous orders is something unpardonable," stated the bench.
The top court went on to direct the chief justice of the Allahabad High Court to immediately withdraw the present "criminal determination" from the judge, and ensure he does not handle any criminal jurisdiction henceforth. P6...
To read the full article or to get the complete feed from this publication, please
Contact Us.