United Kingdom, May 26 -- Jenny McCarthy was "too cool" to be a fan of husband Donnie Wahlberg's boy band New Kids on the Block.

The couple first met in 2012 but the 52-year-old 'Masked Singer' judge insists she wasn't the right age to be into the 'You Got It (The Right Stuff)', who formed in 1984 and became popular in the late-80s and early 90s.

Jenny laughed to PEOPLE: "If I were in my late 40s, I probably would've fit into that slot of New Kid's fan, but I'm 52, going on 53, so I was too cool for that.

"I was really into Madonna, though.

"Like, dressed like her, I'd wear my shirt showing my bra strap. Absolutely loved her."

However, she did see her future husband on TV during his heyday.

She recalled: "The first time I remember s...